Evidence-based vs. the "gold standard": Which is better in medical malpractice lawsuits?

Evidence-based vs. the "gold standard"

With regard to standard of care, which holds more weight in a legal setting: evidence-based practice or the "gold standard?" — JEANENE KENNETT, MSN, RN, FNP-BC, Springfield, Mo.

Hopefully, the gold standard is evidence-based! Having said that, only 30% of standardized care has solid research driving the practice guidelines. The National Guideline Clearinghouse is an excellent resource for evidence-based guidelines. An available guideline trumps common practices that are not evidence-based, and controlled clinical trials always trump expert opinion.  — Rebecca H. Bryan, APRN, CNP (153-09)

More in Consultations

Providing appropriate mental health care for low-income patients

Providing appropriate mental health care for low-income patients

How do I do what is best for the patient if the patient cannot afford a higher level of treatment?

Testing for closed head injury

Testing for closed head injury

What is a good screening test for evaluation of closed head injury?

Diagnosing neutropenia

Diagnosing neutropenia

What constitutes a reasonable workup for neutropenia in an otherwise healthy young person?